Debt is a tricky bastard
First of all, I can’t wait to be debt-free. It’s a slow process, but I love having something to work towards.
I frequently point people to checkout an amortization calculator when discussing mortgages and buying homes. They have shown me how little I knew about personal finance, debt and money in general. Playing around with loan calculators saved me about $10,000 on student loans. That little win motivated me to try and be less ignorant about money and do some research.
So, here is a rough (enlightening) example of just how much information can be learned about future decisions from one of these things.
Magically, your total costs equaled exactly $200,000 for a new home. You have no down payment and your lender isn’t making you get private mortgage insurance because of it (aka, this is not a “real” scenario, only for simplicity sake).
Your only decision is choosing a 15 year or 30 year repayment plan.
30 year
Lets assume 5.2% (from bankrate.com)
$1098.22/mo
Not too bad.
Where are we after 5 years?
Interest paid: $50,863.61
Balance: $183,872.08
Five years & $68k later, we now own about 8% of our $200k home.
15 year
a slightly lower rate: 4.5% (bankrate.com)
Our minimum payment increases to $1530/mo ($432 more than 30 year).
Lets see where we are at after 5 years of paying.
Interest paid: $39,980
Balance: $146,651
The obvious thing, is more money was paid.
$83,329 ($3000/year more).
BUT
$11k less was spent on interest. And now you own 27% of your $200k home, instead of just 7%.
Take a quick peak at the last line of the amortization schedule.
On the 30 year mortgage, you will have paid $395,359.83 for a $200,000 home.
15 year: $275,397.58 for the same $200,000 home.
The end result? Spending an extra $432/month will save you approx $120,000 by not eating out as much, canceling the movie tier on your cable package and brewing your own coffee. If you end up with a larger surplus than $432, you will end up saving another $5-6k for every additional $100 you add to your monthly mortgage payment.
Disclaimer: I don’t know anything about personal finance. I’m just trying to learn. This entire post is only highlighting certain interesting points in time of the report the amortization schedule shows us. Don’t mistake this post as advice. By all means, stimulate the economy, bitch about your debt, overdraft fees and your 11th maxed out credit card.
A few years ago, I was ready to sign over my life for a home with no knowledge beyond “how much do I pay per month”. I’d be really pissed off knowing what I know now, if I had made that mistake.
2 Comments so far
Leave a comment
as someone experiencing this – key points:
larger down payment = nice. Its really hard to save 20% on a home. Take bonus checks, tax returns, whatever, and save it. I didn’t put 20% down, but we did close. Mortgage Insurance is a bitch.
2: Taxes, Taxes, taxes….
Some people have a lot easier than others. Living in a bigger city has required my wife and I to live in a heavier taxed area to keep the riff raff away. Some people might think that is snobby or that i’m being retarded about that — not true. There is a lot to say about having peace of mind about your home. Plus Location-location-location. We pay nearly 4k a year in taxes — That’s like adding another $333 to your payment every month. Hell, my rent in murray wasnt even that much!
3: Home Insurance
Expect around $100+ a month for this. You’ll have to have it. It sucks.
So, suddenly — if you dont have 20% down your paying 1625.00 for your 200k dollar home or 2088.00.
People say renting is a waste of money…. throwing 333 in taxes + 125 PMI + 100 in insurance (vs 30/month for renters insurance) is a joke to me. Rent until you can avoid the 20% or close to it.
If you live somewhere like eddyville, ky or Murray, ky — just buy a nice house, cause your lucky you dont get taxed to death and 200k will buy you a really nice home. haha
By Craig Clayton on 04.20.10 7:30 am
Mr Clayton,
Thanks for the input sir.
There’s so much to know about the whole home buying ridiculousness. Congrats on the house.
By Timothy on 04.20.10 8:27 am
Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>